T.J. Holmes’ perception provides a brand new layer to the surprising cut up, which James introduced earlier this month by way of Instagram.
Article continues beneath commercial
T.J. Holmes Defends Matt James Whereas Acknowledging His Breakup Missteps
In the course of the January 29 episode of their “Amy and T.J.” podcast, addressed the criticism surrounding James’ latest cut up, admitting that whereas he sympathizes with him, he additionally acknowledges that issues might have been dealt with otherwise.
“I’ll defend Matt, however I can defend Matt with out sh-tting on Rachael,” Holmes stated. “I can defend him and have my coronary heart exit to him with out taking something away from her expertise.”
Article continues beneath commercial
Whereas Holmes understands that relationships are sophisticated, he didn’t maintain again when discussing James’ abrupt Instagram breakup put up, which caught Kirkconnell off guard. “If Matt was in entrance of me proper now, I’d say, ‘Rattling, bro, what have been you pondering with that [breakup announcement] put up? Why did you not give it a beat?’” Holmes stated, including that James might need a motive for his actions.
Article continues beneath commercial
Amy Robach Weighs In On James’ Choice

Holmes’ co-host Robach speculated that James could have had a sudden realization that pushed him to finish issues.
“Possibly he had an aha second. Possibly there was simply readability the place he thought, ‘You already know what? I don’t need extra nights like that. I don’t need days like that. I don’t need that,’” Robach theorized. “One thing needed to have modified. One thing needed to have clicked.”
She steered that James’ spending three weeks straight with Kirkconnell could have contributed to his change of coronary heart.
“Possibly everybody ought to do this .. spend three weeks with somebody 24 hours a day. And also you might need readability that you simply didn’t have earlier than,” she added.
Article continues beneath commercial
Holmes jokingly responded to Robach’s feedback by calling them “the very best couple ever” since they spend a lot time collectively. Robach took it a step additional, suggesting they need to “go to the courthouse” and make issues official.
“We now have withstood that check, but it surely’s a check lots of people don’t undergo,” she concluded. “I believe on the finish of the day, a yr from now or six months from now or 5 years from now, there will likely be readability.”
Article continues beneath commercial
T.J. Holmes Says Matt James Had ‘Loads of Conversations’ About Proposing To Rachael Kirkconnell Earlier than Their Break up

Holmes shared that James had brazenly mentioned proposing to Kirkconnell and even envisioned their future collectively. “Matt clearly wasn’t fooling her or making an attempt to trick her,” Holmes stated, earlier than including, “I had loads of conversations with this dude.”
Holmes defined that now that Kirkconnell has publicly spoken out concerning the breakup, he feels extra snug sharing what he is aware of.
“Now that she stated it, I really feel extra snug saying it. He’s talked about marrying this lady. He’s talked about them having youngsters,” Holmes revealed. “He talked about it a lot privately. [I] had this dialog tons of occasions with this dude.”
These revelations make James’ abrupt cut up from Kirkconnell much more puzzling to Bachelor Nation, as simply weeks earlier than the breakup, he reportedly inspired her to start out engagement rings.
Article continues beneath commercial
Rachael Kirkconnell Opens Up About The Breakup

Kirkconnell addressed the cut up on January 28 throughout an emotional episode of the “Name Her Daddy” podcast. She revealed that James in the end expressed doubts about their long-term compatibility, resulting in their breakup.
“He stated that on the finish of the day, there have been simply qualities about me that he worries about having in a spouse,” she shared. “There are issues that we aren’t appropriate with, and the entire accountability and saying sorry and all that was actually the principle factor.”
In keeping with Kirkconnell, James realized he wasn’t prepared for marriage, regardless of their practically four-year relationship. “I ought to wish to suggest to you by this time,” she recalled him saying. “At this level in our relationship, I ought to be wanting these issues and I ought to be prepared for that. However I’m not. I don’t know if I ever see myself proposing to you. I can’t really see myself married to you.”
Holmes, nevertheless, presumed that James and Kirkconnell have been conscious of the challenges of their relationship.
Article continues beneath commercial
“Definitely, a few of these issues have been on his thoughts and talked about [between them]. You’re at all times wanting on the particular person you’ve been in with for a relationship,” Holmes continued earlier than shifting the main target to his personal relationship with Robach. “We’ve been collectively developing on three years now. I guarantee you, I’ve had loads of ideas about you being my spouse.”
A Look At The Future

With Holmes now confirming that James had been fascinated by marriage and youngsters, followers are left questioning what actually induced his change of coronary heart.
Whereas neither James nor Kirkconnell has publicly responded to Holmes’ feedback, it’s clear that there’s extra to this breakup than meets the attention, and Bachelor Nation is right here for the drama.