Is the love track dying? NPR’s Juana Summers speaks David Mora and Michelle Jia about their latest essay in The Pudding, which got down to reply that query.
JUANA SUMMERS, HOST:
Love songs have been round for a really very long time.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “AT LAST”)
ETTA JAMES: (Singing) Eventually…
SUMMERS: Are at this time’s musicians nonetheless writing about love, or is the love track dying?
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “AT LAST”)
JAMES: (Singing) …My love has come alongside.
SUMMERS: That is the query David Mora and Michelle Jia got down to reply of their latest essay in The Pudding. They regarded on the prime 10 hottest songs for yearly from 1959 to 2023 to attempt to determine it out. David and Michelle, welcome to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED.
MICHELLE JIA: Thanks.
DAVID MORA: Thanks.
SUMMERS: What impressed the 2 of you to look into this?
MORA: Yeah. We had been actually all in favour of how artists current themselves not simply as themselves, however as characters in a narrative or in a persona throughout time and the way that is modified as society has modified. And as we had been exploring that, we began to consider the best way that these performers – whether or not that is Nicki Minaj or Elvis – associated to like and romance, which is so central on this complete dataset in pop.
And we began to ask this query, you understand, there’s a lot grumbling, notably from the older technology, about how love has been misplaced, true romance is not represented anymore, that we stated, effectively, is that this actually there within the knowledge? And what we discovered was actually stunning and attention-grabbing and allow us to simply fully change the best way we considered what’s love and the way will we speak about it.
SUMMERS: OK, and once we strive to determine whether or not musicians are nonetheless writing about love or whether or not the love track’s dying, I imply, to reply that query, I really feel like you have to outline what a love track even is. And in your essay, you begin by songs that you simply classify as serenade. So these are type of, like, probably the most simple songs about love, like “Cannot Assist Falling In Love” by Elvis Presley.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “CAN’T HELP FALLING IN LOVE”)
ELVIS PRESLEY: (Singing) Sensible males say…
SUMMERS: What makes a serenade a serenade?
JIA: I feel when folks think about love songs, there’s virtually two huge classes. The primary one is the apparent one, which is you the singer are in love with somebody, and also you’re singing to them direct. And that is what a serenade is. It is like a declaration of affection from one individual to the opposite. The second sort, like every part else, is there’s a complete world of songs which might be about love, however aren’t that direct. And that is what the remainder of the essay will get into.
SUMMERS: Based on your evaluation, the recognition of serenades has declined from 23% of prime songs to solely like 12% of prime songs. However you two make the case on this essay, David, that that’s not sufficient to show that the love track is lifeless. Inform us why.
MORA: Yeah. Properly, clearly, you might have a quite simple relationship once you love somebody, they love you again and every part is nice. However there’s a lot extra mentioned in pop. And I feel we began kind of with the serenade, the place love is nice and every part’s easy. And I feel the apparent class could be when there’s heartache. There’s the second class; songs like “Yesterday” by the Beatles.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “YESTERDAY”)
THE BEATLES: (Singing) I stated one thing incorrect. Now I lengthy for yesterday.
SUMMERS: All proper. Now, I’ve acquired a query, if I can, about these songs about pursuing love. There are two examples that come to thoughts for me. There’s one thing like, say, “I Need To Maintain Your Hand” by the Beatles. And, fully totally different universe, there’s one thing like “Purchase U A Drink” (ph) by T-Ache, that are two songs that anyone who hears them is aware of, they don’t sound something alike. And but you guys make the case that, lyrically, they’re fairly related. Inform us how.
JIA: I feel we are likely to get caught up in style or in type lots once we take into consideration music, and so we’re like, oh, yeah, T-Ache, like, that is so sonically totally different from the Beatles. However as a result of we targeted on lyrics, we had been in a position to drill down into, like, what’s really taking place on this T-Ache track?
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “BUY U A DRANK (SHAWTY SNAPPIN’)”)
T-PAIN: (Singing) Child lady, what’s your title?
JIA: He is within the bar. He desires to purchase somebody a drink. That is truthfully actually weak. Like, I do know you are T-Ache, however what if she says no? Like, that is nonetheless…
SUMMERS: What if she says no?
JIA: What if – she would possibly say no. So it is, like, nonetheless that second of you see somebody, you are type of into them and you make this gesture in direction of additional closeness. And each these songs are about that.
SUMMERS: Properly, let’s dig into one other class. And we is not going to get too soiled right here as a result of we’re on the radio, however there may be additionally the sexual confidence class, which was just about nonexistent within the ’60s, after which there was this big surge of recognition within the 2000s. What do you assume that every one of those tendencies present us about how the expression of affection and music has modified over time?
JIA: Sexual confidence was an enormous class for us as a result of we knew it was type of, like, the elephant within the room. Loads of the occasions when folks speak concerning the, quote-unquote, “decline of affection songs,” they normally consult with the rise of songs which might be primarily about intercourse. And one factor that we felt strongly about is there’s a complete spectrum of human connection and the way we take into consideration that. And there is many various methods, you understand, culturally, morally to consider the place intercourse and romance sit subsequent to one another. However for us, we had been like, that is all a part of human connection, and this must be a legitimate a part of human expression.
SUMMERS: David, in case you can, may you give us possibly a few examples of these sexual assured songs? I am having a tough time not picturing one Justin Timberlake in my head proper now.
MORA: Yeah. So one iconic one from the early ’80s was “Bodily” by Olivia Newton-John.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “PHYSICAL”)
OLIVIA NEWTON-JOHN: (Singing) Let’s get bodily, bodily.
MORA: In the event you consider fashionable ones, you might have “Work” by Rihanna and Drake. You even have “WAP” with Cardi B and Megan Thee Stallion.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “WAP”)
CARDI B AND MEGAN THEE STALLION: (Rapping) Now get your boots and your coat for this moist, moist, moist. He purchased a cellphone only for footage of this moist, moist, moist.
MORA: And so I feel it is actually attention-grabbing to see how clearly the tone, the explicitness of the songs has modified over time, however I feel that that sexual confidence was there within the ’60s. They might be totally different kind. And possibly now it is turning into extra acceptable to specific it in different methods, but it surely’s nonetheless there. So though we see the surge within the 2000s and since then to modern-day, I feel that we nonetheless see the thread operating by way of all of pop.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “WAP”)
CARDI B AND MEGAN THEE STALLION: (Rapping) I wanna whoop.
SUMMERS: David Mora and Michelle Jia, thanks for becoming a member of us. You may learn the complete piece on The Pudding’s web site. Thanks.
JIA: Thanks.
MORA: Thanks.
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional data.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content will not be in its remaining kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could range. The authoritative report of NPR’s programming is the audio report.