“Lilith Honest: Constructing a Thriller” remembers the success of the woman-led music competition created by singer Sarah McLachlan. McLachlan and documentarian Ally Pankiw discuss concerning the movie.
LEILA FADEL, HOST:
Music festivals are sometimes full of dudes, dudes and extra dudes. Within the late ’90s, a gaggle of organizers tried one thing completely different – put ladies first. Business insiders mentioned, not an opportunity it will work. However Lilith Honest was a smash.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “LILITH FAIR: BUILDING A MYSTERY”)
INDIGO GIRLS: (Singing) Nearer I’m to wonderful, yeah.
FADEL: Individuals flocked to see musicians just like the Indigo Women, Sheryl Crow, Erykah Badu and the principle driver of the competition, Sarah McLachlan. There is a documentary on Hulu proper now trying again on what they achieved. It is known as “Lilith Honest: Constructing A Thriller.” We’ll hear from director Ally Pankiw in a bit. However first, Sarah McLachlan advised me what the ambiance was like within the music trade on the time.
SARAH MCLACHLAN: It was nonetheless very male-dominated. There was an perspective that you can not play ladies back-to-back on the radio, and also you actually could not have them play collectively on tour. Like, I might go…
FADEL: That is wild.
MCLACHLAN: …Into radio stations on a regular basis, and so they’d say, oh, effectively, we love your tune. However we actually cannot add it this week as a result of we added Tracy Chapman, or as a result of we added Jewel, or we added Sinead O’Connor. And I am like, effectively, that is extraordinarily irritating, to bang up towards that on a regular basis.
FADEL: So Lilith Honest involves be, and also you begin with only a few reveals. And persons are form of telling you, Sarah, this isn’t going to work. What are you doing?
MCLACHLAN: Nicely, hassle is we had been already doing it, you understand?
(LAUGHTER)
FADEL: And it was working.
MCLACHLAN: It was working, yeah. We did 4 reveals in 1996, form of a take a look at run. And we bought out, like, 15,000-, 20,000-seat amphitheaters.
FADEL: Let’s hear a clip from the movie. That is singer-songwriter Paula Cole.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “LILITH FAIR: BUILDING A MYSTERY”)
PAULA COLE: And we realized, like, that is one thing that is a lot greater than us or what we even thought it might be. There was magic within the air, and that was the primary day of Lilith Honest.
FADEL: Ally, going again to the late ’90s to doc what Lilith Honest meant to folks – means to folks – I imply, why was it essential to revisit this second in time now?
ALLY PANKIW: I feel it is, like, the right second, sadly. I feel that interval of popular culture, like, taught me how to take a look at myself and the way to consider myself as a younger lady and as a younger homosexual particular person. It is only a blueprint for a greater strategy to do issues as a result of there was a spot within the trade. There wasn’t actually a whole lot of protected areas for girls the place they may go to a competition or devour reside music.
FADEL: Yeah.
PANKIW: And so it was positively filling a spot – noticed a requirement and crammed it. And, like, that is simply good enterprise.
FADEL: Yeah.
MCLACHLAN: I imply, it was virtually form of an antithesis of the way in which I used to be raised, too, which was, you understand, do not go considering you are something particular. And, you’ll fail. Why would you even strive? And I am like…
FADEL: Aww.
MCLACHLAN: And it was all about proving my mom mistaken. So, you understand, thanks, Mother.
(LAUGHTER)
FADEL: It labored out. There is a element on this movie that I did not learn about. And it was one other actually heartbreaking second to observe as a lady, which is how the Grammys handled among the Lilith Honest artists that swept the awards that evening.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “LILITH FAIR: BUILDING A MYSTERY”)
UNIDENTIFIED PRESENTER: And the Grammy goes to Shawn Colvin and John Leventhal.
FADEL: But they’ve this diminishing expertise on the Grammys.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “LILITH FAIR: BUILDING A MYSTERY”)
SHAWN COLVIN: However then Paula Cole, Sarah McLachlan and I had been requested to share the stage and do that medley as an alternative of every of us with the ability to play our personal songs.
MCLACHLAN: And that is one thing that occurs rather a lot within the Grammys. They love to do these mashups. However on the time, contemplating the massiveness of our success, it felt similar to as soon as once more, we had been taking a step backwards and being lumped into this cool class of, oh, simply ladies. The ladies are going to perform a little medley. And but, you understand, R. Kelly and Hanson are – you understand, get their very own full observe.
FADEL: Wow.
MCLACHLAN: And I am like, actually? You already know, in some methods, we must always have simply mentioned, [expletive]. We’re not doing it. However but they might have simply gotten another person to fill the slot. So we thought, OK, effectively, this can be a minute and 30 seconds that we every get to play to, you understand, the largest viewers we have in all probability ever had on nationwide tv. However we weren’t that joyful about it.
FADEL: Yeah.
PANKIW: It felt a bit, like, punitive. It simply felt like after yearly of Lilith, it was like, we wish to remind you – do not get too highly effective. Do not get…
MCLACHLAN: Yeah. Do not assume you are greater than your self. Do not get too excited.
FADEL: Yeah.
MCLACHLAN: Yeah.
FADEL: You oversaw three years in a row of this competition. Why’d you cease?
MCLACHLAN: I finished as a result of I used to be completely exhausted. I had given my entire world to Lilith for 3 years, so I actually needed to have a bit extra of a traditional life. So I assume I may say it was egocentric. However, you understand, I really feel like we did what we got down to do and did a lot greater than that.
FADEL: Do you see something, Sarah, within the music trade at this time that is modified for the higher, maybe due to Lilith Honest?
MCLACHLAN: I imply, I – you understand, I am not going to say it is due to Lilith Honest, as a result of there’s many issues that come into play. However I’ll say that we positively modified – we pressured the change of attitudes throughout the trade in the direction of ladies and in the direction of their industrial viability. I see artists like Taylor Swift in full management of her profession, reaching stratosphere heights and championing ladies alongside her, folks like Brandi Carlile championing ladies, championing queer artists in ways in which we by no means used to have.
FADEL: I used to be fascinated about Taylor Swift and Beyonce. Like, they actually transfer markets. Like, I feel with Beyonce, all this cowboy apparel simply bought out. You possibly can’t even get it anyplace due to what she did.
MCLACHLAN: Oh, they alter a metropolis’s economic system…
FADEL: Yeah.
MCLACHLAN: …Each time they arrive to their market.
FADEL: It is superb.
MCLACHLAN: I imply, it is superb.
FADEL: Ally, similar query to you.
PANKIW: Yeah. I imply, I see younger feminine artists advocating for themselves in a means that is like, no, I do not wish to put on that. I do not need you to power me to put on what I do not wish to put on. I wish to work with the director I wish to work with. I feel that Lilith undeniably made the trail simpler for us to stroll by means of each door.
FADEL: We have been speaking concerning the new documentary “Lilith Honest: Constructing A Thriller.” That is now streaming on Hulu. My visitors – director Ally Pankiw and the founding father of Lilith Honest, Sarah McLachlan. And Sarah has a brand new album out, by the way in which. It is known as “Higher Damaged.” And it is your first album, I feel, in virtually a decade, proper? Your tenth album.
MCLACHLAN: Yeah, 11 years, really.
FADEL: 11 years. Thanks each a lot.
PANKIW: Thanks.
MCLACHLAN: Thanks a lot.
(SOUNDBITE OF FILM, “LILITH FAIR: BUILDING A MYSTERY”)
MCLACHLAN: (Singing) You are constructing a thriller.
(CHEERING)
Copyright © 2025 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for additional info.
Accuracy and availability of NPR transcripts could fluctuate. Transcript textual content could also be revised to appropriate errors or match updates to audio. Audio on npr.org could also be edited after its unique broadcast or publication. The authoritative document of NPR’s programming is the audio document.